Episode
Menachot 103 - April 24, 7 Iyar
- Podcast
- Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
- Published
- Apr 24, 2026
- Duration seconds
- 2970
- Processing state
not_requested- Canonical source
- https://hadran.org.il/daf/menachot-103-2/
Actions
POST https://stenobird.com/v1/public/podcasts/daf-yomi-for-women-hadran-638456/episodes/menachot-103-april-24-7-iyar/transcription-requests
Idempotently request low-priority transcript generation for this episode.GET https://stenobird.com/podcast/daf-yomi-for-women-hadran-638456/menachot-103-april-24-7-iyar.md
Read the agent-friendly Markdown representation of this episode resource.
Summary
There is a dispute regarding a case where someone vowed to bring a mincha of barley. The Tana Kama says that because such a thing does not exist, we obligate them to bring a mincha of wheat. Rabbi Shimon disagrees and says that what was said is nothing, as there is no voluntary mincha of barley. Chizkiya and Rabbi Yochanan attempt to understand the Tana Kama's position. For Chizkiya, it is based on the view of Beit Shammai who hold that we seize the first expression - the statement "I take upon myself a mincha " already creates an obligation to bring a wheat offering, and what one said afterward (where perhaps it was a retraction ) is not accepted at all because it is too late. According to Rabbi Yochanan, who establishes an u kimta for the Mishna, it refers to a case where, when told there is no mincha of barley, the person says that they did not know, and had they known, t he y would have vowed wheat. There is another dispute in our Mishna between Chizkiya and Rabbi Yochanan that appears to present opinions opposite to what they said previously, but the Gemara explains the matter. Chizkiya retracted and agreed with Rabbi Yochanan, while Rabbi Yochanan challenged his retraction and explained how Chizkiya could have explained the words of the Mishna according to his original logic. Zeiri limits the words of the Mishna to a case where one said "I take upon myself a mincha ...", but if one did not say " mincha " but rather "I take upon myself barley" or "I take upon myself a barley mincha ," we do not apply the principle of seizing the first expression. Rava challenges Rav Nachman regarding Zeiri's words based on our Mishna, but Rav Nachman resolves his challenges. One who volunteers to bring more than sixty issaron must bring sixty in one vessel and the remainder in ano…